Obtaining Audit Services Bids from a Client is an Act Discreditable to the Profession
The KPMG-Australia confidential client information leak and data misuse began in May 2024, when a whistleblower sent a detailed internal report to the firm’s leadership before exiting. The whistleblower submitted evidence that senior partners misused confidential board documents (including from property group Lendlease) to gain an unfair advantage in winning audit bids for clients. The whistleblower pointed to a faulty ethical culture and poor speak-up culture.
Australian Senator Deborah O’Neill, used parliamentary privilege to publicly expose the allegations, causing the scandal to erupt into the open in March 2026. At a parliamentary hearing in Canberra, Australia, O’Neill said more people were reporting similar conduct.
KPMG initially said the claims were unsubstantiated. However, CEO Andrew Yates, who joined the firm in 1990 and became CEO in 2021, resigned after its investigation into the whistleblower’s allegations “fell short of the firm’s expectations, those of the whistleblower and the broader community”, the firm said in a statement. Eventually, KPMG acknowledged mishandling the whistleblower complaint and launched a fourth internal investigation in 2026 after previous ones failed to substantiate any wrongdoing.
New-CEO John Sams told a Parliamentary hearing that the firm had committed “major failings here that we have to reflect on, and I’m not going to try and defend any of those because they’re indefensible.” “We can’t go with the ‘few bad apples’ line here, we absolutely have to look at our culture,” he said.
The Case of Eileen Hoggett
Former audit partner Eileen Hoggett, who the whistleblower said stored audit client Lendlease board papers in her locker, told the committee she did not recall stashing the files, and did not understand why she was expelled from the partnership. A May 2023 email presented to the committee showed Hoggett authorized a colleague to view the documents in her locker to help with a bid for another proposal. “‘I think we confidentially allow him to look at the printed version in my locker … he needs to do it sensitively without letting too many people know’,” O’Neill read.
“I find it hard that if you’ve written that email, you’re struggling to recall the use of this document that was in your locker that your (executive assistant) was providing access to,” O’Neill said. Hoggett replied: “There is no one more disappointed in me than myself.”
The Case of Lendlease
The allegations on Lendlease, the property giant that had been a KPMG audit client for nearly seven decades, allege that a former KPMG Australia audit director and senior partners accessed and copied restricted Lendlease board papers, including rival pitch strategies from EY and PwC, to help the firm win competing audit work from Westpac, Dexus, and Macquarie. KPMG Australia was charged with misusing confidential corporate client data to gain new commercial clients followed by a failure to act on internal whistleblowers. As a result of the scandal, the firm had commercial losses including losing the A$75 million (about $53 US dollars) Macquarie Group audit contract.
KPMG’s Culpability
Singapore Telecommunications-owned Optus, whose data was shared with another internal team bidding for an audit contract for its rival Telstra, called KPMG’s conduct an “egregious” and “flagrant” breach of professional duties. “They need to remind themselves that they are first and foremost professionals, and that business issues are secondary to those professional responsibilities,” Chairman John Arthur said.
At Westpac, director Peter Nash resigned from the bank’s board due to his ties with the auditing firm. Kim Lawry, a senior KPMG Australia audit and assurance partner who served as the lead auditor for Westpac, also resigned in July 2026 after Westpac requested her removal as its lead auditor. Westpac’s audit committee chair Michael Ullmer told the hearing Nash should not have contacted his former KPMG colleagues during the tender process.
A government senator, Barbara Pocock, said in a statement that the hearing revealed further evidence of KPMG’s “toxic culture” and reinforced the case for sector reform. “They have misled the parliament and the public, and drip fed us self-congratulatory whitewash and misinformation.”
The Australian Department of Finance
The Australian Department of Finance issued its Independent Review of KPMG Australia on October 14, 2026, and offered eight recommendations. Of the report’s key findings, it was determined that KPMG failed to respond appropriately to the whistleblower’s concerns and that the firm’s policies, reporting channels and oversight structures did not operate effectively in practice to provide the necessary support, risk identification, or ensure timely decision making. The report said: “The firm focused more heavily on the legal status of the disclosure, the allegations, and the risks to the organization…and too little on the possibility that the whistleblower’s broader allegations might be correct.”
KPMG has opposed the strongest measures under consideration, including the separation of audit and consulting arms, or placing caps on partnerships, according to a submission published by the firm. The investigation is ongoing.
Acts Discreditable
Acts Discreditable cover a broad range of actions that may bring discredit to the accounting profession. Acts Discreditable create threats to an auditor’s independence. KPMG received confidential information on the bids of competitive firms that seek to provide services to a potential client. If the firm receives such internal, proprietary information, it could potentially impair objectivity and integrity in meeting professional responsibilities. This is exactly what happened to KPMG.
Concluding Thoughts
KPMG Australia has spent the better part of two years losing a CEO, a chairman, a COO, government contracts worth hundreds of millions of dollars, and, by its own admission, the trust of clients it had audited for decades. All of it traces back to the whistleblower email sent in May 2024, warning that senior partners were misusing confidential client data to chase new business. What happened after that email is a case study in how quickly a firm can unravel when an investigation fails and a culture protects the wrong people.
Blog posted by Steven Mintz, PhD, professor emeritus from Cal Poly San Luis Obispo, on November 18, 2026. You can contact Steve at: smintz@calpoly.edu. Visit his website to find out more about his activities.